Synorigin

When an idea is mostly a known genre skeleton

A premise that is very close to two of the most famous stories in the genre - and a check that said so without softening it.

This result is from a Claude Sonnet 5 session using the exact system prompt now in production, run before live web search was integrated. Reasoning and tone match the live app; matches were found from training knowledge, not live search.

What was being tested

Whether the check would call this what it plainly is, or soften it - and whether the verdict would stay honest when the honest answer is discouraging.

The idea submitted

A chosen-one teenager discovers on their 16th birthday that they are the last of an ancient magical bloodline, and must master their powers before a dark lord who has hunted their family for generations finds them.

What Synorigin returned

Closest matches

The originality gap

What is derivative is the mechanism of revelation and threat. The antagonist's motive is currently a placeholder - "hunted for generations" is generic evil.

The pivot

Make the bloodline's power something the dark lord needs rather than fears. That flips prophecy-fulfilment into an extraction dynamic, which is a different story shape entirely.

Verdict

About 85% a known genre skeleton as written - the gap above is what would pull it out of Harry Potter and Star Wars territory.

Why this result matters

The two most obvious comparisons were named directly, and the percentage was called high rather than rounded down into something more comfortable. That is the behaviour the tool exists for.

The pivot is also worth reading closely. It does not say "add something original." It changes one specific relationship - what the antagonist wants - and that single change alters the genre the story belongs to.

Sharing a trope is not the same as copying. Every one of these matches shares tropes with hundreds of other books. What makes this premise derivative is that the tropes arrive in the same arrangement, which is a structural fact rather than a judgement about the writer.

Related

Check your own idea